Many taxpayers - regardless of credit history - jumped last year to take advantage of a $7,500 tax credit for first time home buyers. The advantage of this credit was that it was refundable--even if you didn't owe $7,500 in taxes you got the whole credit. For example if you owed $2,500, your credit covered that debt and the government cut you a check for $5,000. The downside was that over a 15 year period, the credit had to be repaid.
Then, Congress passed the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009. This new bill increases the credit to $8,000 and that $8,000 doesn't have to be repaid. How does this new bill affect those who took the $7,500 credit?
Unfortunately, if you took the $7,500, you can't take the new $8,000 credit. And you still have to repay the $7,500 back over 15 years. But you don't have to start repayment for a couple of years, and the value of getting $7,500 at no interest for many years still comes to about $4,000. So while the $7,500 you got may not give you warm fuzzies, it's better than a sharp stick and still a good deal.
Now for those who have not bought a house yet, there may be all kinds of goodies available to you, depending on your income.
* Mortgage Credit Certificate Programs These create a tax advantage for first-time buyers. It's pretty much free money if you meet the IRS income guidelines and your home purchase doesn't exceed a predetermined amount. An MCC allows you to deduct your mortgage interest and adds a 20% tax credit towards your income tax liability. And the lender will deduct that credit from your house payment when calculating your debt to income ratios, qualifying you for a larger loan than you otherwise could.
* A refundable $8,000 credit for first-time homebuyers. And many folks who have owned property in the past still qualify for "first time homebuyer" status. Check here to see if you qualify. Here are the details:
· The tax credit does not have to be repaid.
· The tax credit is equal to 10 percent of the home's purchase price up to a maximum of $8,000.
· The credit is available for homes purchased on or after January 1, 2009 and before December 1, 2009.
· Single taxpayers with incomes up to $75,000 and married couples with incomes up to $150,000 qualify for the full tax credit.
· If you have not filed your taxes yet for 2008 and you close on a home before you do so, you may be able to apply it on your 2008 tax return. Check with a tax pro for details.
* Rural Housing Programs You'd be amazed at what's considered rural by the USDA. Programs include zero down payment options for qualifying buyers in qualifying areas. And on February 1st, these rates dropped to 4.375%. Check out the details here.
So 2009 brings a lot of good reasons to buy a home. FHA and USDA lending guidelines are fairly liberal, and first timers can catch a lot of breaks from the IRS. When it comes to home buying, the US government loves newbies. Talk about beginner's luck.
You can start your search by contacting our database of new home loan lenders to request a mortgage prequalification letter from mortgage lenders; if you have a property in mind already, you can request up to four free competing mortgage quotes. If you already have a property, given current low market rates, consider requesting mortgage refinance quotes through our mortgage lender matching service. Good luck!
40 Responses to "They Passed the Stimulus Bill: Do I Have to Pay Back My $7,500 Tax Credit?!?"
I closed on my home December 31, 2008 at 9:00 PM - imagine how I feel. I don't mind paying it back, but it is unfair that all those that came the next day (few hours) do not have to pay.
Yeah i'm upset. Settlemnt day dec 29th 2008 so i missed the 8k and no repayment by days, days! Such garbage...i called the irs and unless you are 2009 to start there is nothing you can do. So options are to die or burn down your house so you dont have to repay. Well not all the options but i wish i had not listened to my realtor to close by end of year and done it by feb of 2009 as i wanted to originally.
Has there been any latest updates from the IRS on those (like me who purchased in 2008) who have to re-pay back the $7,500 credit?
Sandy: The $8000 credit doesn't have to be repaid. And neither credit has to be repaid if you sell the house with no profit or lose it in foreclosure.
Ive bought a house 1 year ago, got the 8000 tax credit, put it all back into the house. circumstances changed, Alot for me, if I sell, or file bankruptsy, will I have to pay this back?
http://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc611.html This explains how they determine how much, if any, of your credit gets recaptured. "For purposes of calculating gain, the adjusted basis of such residence shall be reduced by the amount of the first-time homebuyer credit allowed, to the extent not previously recaptured. In the case of an involuntary conversion, recapture is not accelerated if a new principal residence is acquired within a 2-year period. No amount is recaptured after the death of the taxpayer."
Hope that helps -- you do have to count whatever credits you got (less what you have already repaid) when determining your adjusted basis. Great question; thanks for submitting.
Gina,
I hope that you are still willing to reply to an article you published over a year ago!
In your comment April 20, 2009, you said "The gain on your sale is determined by the proceeds of the sale less the acquisition." I understand that the cost of acquisition (adjusted cost basis) is the price I bought the home for, improvements I have put in, and some qualifying closing costs. It seems that in terms of having to pay income tax on gains for a house lived in less than 2 years, costs associated with selling the house are deducted from the proceeds, and hence narrow the gap between acquisition and proceed of sale.
For instance, if I paid $200k for the house, put in $15k in permanent improvements, and $1500 in qualified closing costs, my acquisition price is now $216,500. Then subtracting my $7500 homebuyer credit, my acquisition price is really $209k. I sell the house for $220k and pay say $12k in agent commissions and advertising, meaning I have a take home of $208k, an amount less than my adjusted cost basis. So for the purposes of the recapture, does the IRS look at the sales price of $220k and say that I had a gain, or do they look at my net of $208k, and acknowledge that I have had a loss - hence not having to repay the $7500 tax credit? Thanks so much for your help!
I closed on my home in April of 2008 & received the $7500 "credit", but now have filed for bankruptcy. How will this impact the repaying of the "credit"? I can't seem to locate an answer anywhere. Help please!!
Every tax season for the next 15 years I will be pissed off that I have to pay back this $7500 'credit' while people who bought their first houses just three months later do not.
Why wasn't the $7500 payback dropped when the new credit was formed?! Like the other commenters here, I was told to jump at the opportunity to get in on the $7500 credit. I could have waited three months had I known I would be getting $8000 ABSOLUTELY FREE. Now the credit has been extended and continues to increase in scope. Talk about salt in the wound. Isn't there something 2008 buyers who feel ripped-off can do?
TO EVERYONE THAT HAS TO PAY BACK!
We need to act! We can not let this happen to us. There are alot of you here that can get this changed. We can start a signature petition and with enough signatures we can have this overturned. Who is with me?
e-mail me at throllballen@yahoo.com
Let's get organized and get this unjustice changed!
Teresa, you do not start paying the $7500 back until tax year of 2010. It was defered for a year.
I think it is rediculous in this economy how the $7500 group has to pay thier money back and the $8000(new home) & $6500 (previous owners) group do not have to pay anything back... Does anyone know of a protest website as to where the $7500 group wont have to pay it back if there are enough replies??
My wife and I didn't build and buy our house just to get or becuase of a tax "credit", but any money is good money, I guess? The timing was the right timing for us. A month later though things change and everybody gets 8-15K FREE. Now we still owe? What gives.
Rudy,
Sorry I did find that out ages ago when I answered another question but didn't put that in the blog; I put it in an article instead. Hope if didn't cause any confusion.
2009 was the year 29 of january
i signed the contract on january last signature of the house contract but lady at the income tax said i was going to qualify for 7500 why is that
Question, we got the 7500 tax credit and my husband is in the army we got orders and had to sell are house because the gov moved us. what will happen this year when we do are taxes?
Question, I applied for the 7500 tax credit and have not received the check as of yet. It has been 4 months I was wandering that if I file my 2010 taxes will I have to pay the 500 back even if I have not gotten the check yet? I called the IRS 3 times they say still processing.
Actually gina, I believe if you rent out the home you purchased in 2008, you have to pay back the 7500 immediately. I'm just finding myself in this predicament.
There isn't much anyone can do. It's kind of like people who buy a car with a $3,000 discount and then Cash for Clunkers comes along with $4500. But those who were okay with $3,000 already bought their cars. It's a risk you take when you buy anything--I got plane tickets for $500 and a week later I could have bought them for $120. When a deal seems good you have to take it; I would have done the same in your shoes.
I agree I feel like I did the right thing and went out and bought a house bc it was the right thing for me to do, not to get 7500.00 and now people are buying houses to get 8000.00 and its free money and I get to start paying my 7500.00 back next year ...whats wrong with this and what should I do....call or write???
Question Cont'd: I wanted to add that I bought the condo for 149K and got a piggy back loan for the down payment so I ended up owing 157K - The homes in that area are dropping in value about 1% per month. So the place is now has, I guess you'd call it negative equity as it is now worth less than I paid for it and it looks like that will not change any time in the foreseeable future.
Thanks again for and suggestions,
Blake
Question: I closed on my home in August of 2008 and took the $7500 tax credit. It was a long commute to work and I have back problems. I fell at work and making the existing condition worse and finall had to get a studio across the street from where I work in 2009. The value of my condo also dropped by 20,000. My question is can I rent it out without having to pay back the credit to offset the cost now that I have rent and a mortgage payment. It won't be long before I am out of savings.
Thanks, Blake
Question: When you are selling your house, does it matter the loan amount(including closing costs) that you clear for repaying the tax credit or what we paid only for the house? What if what we paid for the house is less than what the house is worth? My husband is military and we bought a house a year ago and now we have orders to japan for the next three years. So we are trying to sell.
Thanks
I believe the payback applies as long as you own the home and is not dependent on whether you live in it.
The problem in my opinion with people being allowed to use the $8,000 for a down payment (FHA was going to try it but suspended the program) is that the whole subprime problem and FHA defaults too began when builders and other parties were allowed to contribute the down payments. A study by HUD found that borrowers pretty much equal in every way were far more likely to blow off their mortgages if they had nothing down than those tho put up even 2%. It makes a huge difference. And as tax payers, do we really want to give these guys down payments, allow them to walk away if it doesn't work out, and stick us with another bill?
I guess it's kind of like the reason why my grades went up so much when I went to college and had to pay for it myself.....